Bitget App
Trade smarter
Buy cryptoMarketsTradeFuturesCopyBotsEarn
Judge in Coinbase case says SEC’s securities definition may be too broad

Judge in Coinbase case says SEC’s securities definition may be too broad

Crypto SlateCrypto Slate2024/01/18 01:23
By:Mike Dalton

The judge nevertheless declined to rule on or dismiss the case today.

A court hearing between Coinbase and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) took place on Jan. 17 concerning earlier charges.

In June 2023, the SEC alleged that Coinbase illegally operated a unregistered national securities exchange, broker, and clearing agency and that its crypto staking service involved the unregistered sale and offering of securities.

Though Judge Katherine Polk Failla did not provide a ruling or judgment today, she expressed concerns in line with those of Coinbase.

According to Reuters , Judge Failla commented on 13 crypto tokens that Coinbase provides customers with access to but does not issue, and which the SEC considers securities. The judge questioned the SEC’s arguments, stating:

“I am concerned… that what you’re asking for is to broaden the definition of what constitutes a security.”

The SEC’s assistant chief litigation counsel, Patrick Costello, instead argued that the crypto tokens in question are part of a larger enterprise (ie. blockchain network) and are therefore akin to investment contracts. He added that the value of each token increases as the value of the network or ecosystem grows. By extension, each asset could be considered a security as the case develops.

According to The Block , Costello conceded that token issuers had “not exactly” violated securities laws. The companies behind Cardano (ADA), Solana (ADA), and Polygon (MATIC) have previously denied those assets’ securities status and are not named as defendants the SEC’s case against Coinbase.

Hearing also addressed dismissal

FOX Business reporter Eleanor Terrett also reported on the hearing. According to Terrett’s account, Judge Failla asked the SEC why she should not dismiss the case, a course of action requested by Coinbase itself .

The judge cited Senator Cynthia Lummis’ support for a dismissal, calling Lummis “not just a random Senator” but “deeply involved in the space.” The judge paraphrased an earlier statement in which Lummis implied the outdatedness of securities tests, stating: “We’ve had a good run. We’ve had 90 years where these securities laws have been able to apply to these markets.”

Terrett went on to describe closing arguments . The SEC argued that Coinbase is misapplying the Howey Test of 1934 and denied any “easy workaround.”

Coinbase responded that the SEC has not shown that token issuers have done anything that could be considered a contract with Coinbase customers, stating:

“The Commission’s complaint draws the court into completely unprecedented territory. The SEC should follow enforcement and rulemaking actions that make sense of statutory language and [don’t] twist it upside down. This is several bridges too far and for that reason we ask you to dismiss [the SEC’s case] completely.”

Despite her critical attitude toward the SEC, Judge Failla declined to rule today, according to Terrett. The judge told both sides to take the lack of a decision as a “compliment,” suggesting that each side has a viable argument.

0

Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.

PoolX: Locked for new tokens.
APR up to 10%. Always on, always get airdrop.
Lock now!

You may also like

Elon Musk Sued Over Stock Fraud Twitter

HappyCoinNews2025/01/16 10:44

Thai authorities consider approving bitcoin ETF

HappyCoinNews2025/01/16 10:44

Trump and Musk dine with Microsoft CEO to discuss AI, cybersecurity and American jobs

Share link:In this post: Microsoft Corp.’s Satya Nadella joins Donald Trump and Elon Musk for the discussion of AI and cybersecurity The statement said that the conversation was based on several topics, including the US firm’s pledge to invest $80 billion in AI data centers globally. Over $50 billion of that investment is expected to support American jobs.

Cryptopolitan2025/01/16 09:33

Litecoin ETF may be near SEC approval after Canary Funds amends the filing

Share link:In this post: Canary Capital filed an amended S-1 registration statement for its Litecoin ETF on January 13. Senior ETF analyst at Bloomberg Eric Balchunas believes the SEC’s recent response to Canary’s Litecoin S-1, improves the chances that a Litecoin ETF will be approved soon. Canary Capital also filed its S-1 registration statement for Solana and XRP ETFs in October.

Cryptopolitan2025/01/16 09:33